Smith’s has a $2.00 catalina generating when you buy 2 select Colgate products. Most the Colgate toothpaste products are $2.49-$3.49 right now, which isn’t a good deal. But, I spotted some closeout Colgate items, that do make for a great deal, including the Colgate Sensitive that is pictured.
Here’s one example:
Buy (2) Colgate Sensitive, $1.07 each–closeout price
Buy 2+, Get $2.00 Catalina back
Use (2) $0.50/1 Colgate Toothpaste, exp. 2/14/16 (SS 01/31/16) [3-oz.+; Limit 4]
Pay $1.14, Get $2.00 Catalina back
Final Price: $0.86 moneymaker
**Keep in mind, while not all stores will have this closeout item, it is a good possibility they will. Closeout items are statewide, unlike manager’s specials, which vary store to store.